5

My current org file (e.g. work.org) has 20+ DONE tasks and Org-mode becomes extremely slow: even moving the cursor takes a 2-3 seconds sometimes. I decide I have to archive these DONE tasks, but I found I don't know what Org-mode is actually doing to my text when archiving.

There are a few common options to archive:

  1. archive subtree using the default command C-c C-x C-a It moves my subtree (a DONE task) from work.org to work.org_archive
  2. move subtree to archive file C-c C-x C-s It also moves my subtree from work.org_archive
  3. toggle ARCHIVE tag / to ARCHIVE sibling C-c C-x a/A It greys out my subtree (the DONE task) but the task remains visible on work.org when I expand the top tree. However, details of the subtree is not expandable, unless I do "force cycling of an ARCHIVEd tree" (C-TAB)

My questions are: If I archive using #3, does the content of completed tasks stay in work.org? And does #3 offer already significantly performance improvement over a large Org file?

Also, if I archive using #1 or #2, how can I: Search the archived contents on separate files? Do I just include the :archive: only? Or do I need to list and include all these files in my .emacs under org-agenda-text-search-extra-files?

And how do I refile a subtree by C-c C-w? Is it similar to refiling in other case: i.e. find the subtree in search by other ways, do a C-c C-w to move the subtree to the section I want, and then just save both the target org file and the .org_archive file in question. Is there other things I have to pay attention to?

My Emacs (25.1 64-bit in Windows10) just crashed... Emacs (esp. Org mode) has become so slow and almost inoperable that typing on Firefox is quicker.

  • I tried #3, and did a C-c a and then m to search for tags. None of the :ARCHIVE: entries showed up. Neither in s (search for keywords options) There must be something wrong. – menuhin Nov 24 '16 at 16:56
  • 3
    As a side comment: are you sure emacs is slow because of 20 DONE tasks? Have you tried to delete those and see if still is slow? (backup! backup!) I have a org file (agenda + random notes) with some 2.5k line, 500 bullets (tasks, subtasks, notes), a lot of org-tables, ... and it works "instantly", both on windows and linux. (version 24.3 on linux, similar or older on windows) – Rolazaro Azeveires Nov 24 '16 at 17:20
  • 3
    I should create a separate post on this slow Emacs issue. I have been trying to find the reason why my Emacs has become unusable: I have done a few times profiler-report and I still have to figure out what package these stalling sub-processes belong to. I have also used benchmark-init and tried to downsize my .emacs by removing unnecessary require and load statements and changing them into something else. – menuhin Nov 24 '16 at 18:40
  • 3
    If by chance you have minor-modes active, you may wish to disable them and see if performance gets better. For example, linum-mode causes slow-down in large buffers. – lawlist Nov 25 '16 at 5:39
  • 1
    @menuhin: I maintain at work a huge org file with +100 DONE tasks but the only slowdowns I experienced so far is when building column views. Emacs-25.1 Org 9.0.3 – Dieter.Wilhelm Jan 15 '17 at 13:16
2

It seems Org-mode's archiving function is not popular. Here's what I found:

By using toggle ARCHIVE tag / to ARCHIVE sibling C-c C-x a/A, the content of completed tasks stay in work.org. It seems to me it does not offer significantly performance improvement over a large Org file - if the chunk you have to archive is really large.

One can search archived contents on those separate files (in my case .org_archive files) by including them by the variable "org-agenda-text-search-extra-files" so that they are included in search using "C-c a s"

    (setq org-agenda-text-search-extra-files
          (append
           (sa-find-org-file-recursively "~/Dropbox/Org/" ".org_archive") ;agenda-archives
           (sa-find-org-file-recursively "~/Dropbox/Org/journal/" ".txt") ;journals in .txt
     ))

The function "sa-find-org-file-recursively" that recursively look for files in a folder and its sub-folder can be found here: https://stackoverflow.com/questions/11384516/how-to-make-all-org-files-under-a-folder-added-in-agenda-list-automatically

One caveat is that only the "text search" searches only the Org header text of various levels, but nothing in its body text.

Including the :archive: tag may help when an entry is only tagged :archive: but not really archived. However, when an entry is archived it can only be reached during search when its file is included in the "org-agenda-text-search-extra-files" variable.

To refile an archived entry is quite simple, one can open the corresponding archive file (in Org format) and do a C-c C-w at the entry to be refiled.

  • The problem of slow Emacs is due to an outdated package for Org-mode that use UTF-8 characters (org-bullets) – menuhin Dec 15 '16 at 17:05
  • What does sa-find-org-file-recursively do that directory-files-recursively does not do? – mankoff Apr 14 '17 at 21:00
  • They may perform very similarly. Which package does the directory-files-recursively come from? – menuhin Apr 27 '17 at 17:38

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.