The following answer states, that one must have all recalculating formulas in one #+TBLFM line: https://emacs.stackexchange.com/a/10946/10090. Indeed, when I try the following formulas only the first is recalculated automatically:

|   | Runde | 0 | 1 | 2 | 3 | Resultat |          % |
| ! | name  |   |   |   |   |   result | percentage |
| # | Alice | 1 | 1 | 0 |   |        2 |      66.67 |
| # | Bob   | 0 | 0 | 1 |   |        1 |      33.33 |
#+TBLFM: $7='(+ $<<<..$>>>);N
#+TBLFM: $8='(format "%2.2f" (* (/ 100 (float (+ @3$result..@4$result))) $result));N

When I put them both in one #+TBLFM line as in the following example, it will recalculate both formulas as intended.

|   | Runde | 0 | 1 | 2 | 3 | Resultat |          % |
| ! | name  |   |   |   |   |   result | percentage |
| # | Alice | 1 | 1 | 0 |   |        2 |      66.67 |
| # | Bob   | 0 | 0 | 1 |   |        1 |      33.33 |
#+TBLFM: $7='(+ $<<<..$>>>);N::$8='(format "%2.2f" (* (/ 100 (float (+ @3$result..@4$result))) $result));N

Is there a way to change this, so that it considers the first #+TBLFM line first, then the second, then the third, and so on? As I can already have multiple #+TBLFM lines, this would seem natural to me. The current behavior caused me some headache not understanding "why my second formula worked only sometimes".


As of org-mode 9 you can only do this manually: Place the cursor on the respective #+tblfm: lines and press C-c C-c. Here's the corresponding manual section, which is telling you that org considers only the first #+tblfm: line when otherwise updating the table formulas.

When the amount of formulas is getting too cumbersome to edit the #+tblfm: line itself please try the "formula editor" with C-c ' to edit all the formulas line by line.

  • 1
    That's what I feared. I did not realize however, that the formulas would be on separate lines in the formula editor! So that enables me to still edit them in a readable + manageable way even if there are many. Thanks for mentioning that they will be line by line in the formula editor. – Zelphir Jul 15 '18 at 15:32

Everything is possible since you can arbitrarily modify a buffer temporarily before applying a command with cmdbufmod from the answer to the question about a single tblfm for multiple org tables.

The following code defines an :around advice org-table-multi-tblfm for org-table-recalculate that joins successive #+TBLFM:-lines before running org-table-recalculate.

There is an exception: if point is placed at a TBLFM:-line only that formula is evaluated and if point is placed behind the last vertical line | only the first TBLFM:-line is executed. That means you must really put point in the table to get the effect of the around advice.

(defun cmdbufmod-prepare (bufmod-list &optional start bound)
  "Prepare buffer for `cmdbufmod' with modifications BUFMOD-LIST.
See `cmdbufmod' for the format of BUFMOD-LIST.
If START is a buffer position the search for the regular expressions in BUFMOD-LIST
starts there. Otherwise it starts at `point-min'.
Optional BOUND limits the search.
Return the list of original text sections.
Each text section is a cons of an insertion marker and the old text
that needs to be restored there."
  (unless start (setq start (point-min)))
  (let (original-list)
      (dolist (bufmod bufmod-list)
    (let ((place (car bufmod))
          (newtext (cdr bufmod)))
      (goto-char start)
      (while (if (functionp place)
               (funcall place bound)
              (re-search-forward place bound t))
        (setq original-list
          (cons (cons (set-marker (make-marker) (match-beginning 0))
                  (match-string 0))
        (replace-match (propertize (if (functionp newtext)
                       (funcall newtext)
                       'cmdbufmod t 'rear-nonsticky '(cmdbufmod)))))))

(defun cmdbufmod-cleanup (original-list)
  "Restore original text sections from ORIGINAL-LIST.
See the return value of `cmdbufmod-prepare' for the structure of ORIGINAL-LIST."
  (cl-loop for interval being the intervals property 'cmdbufmod
       if (get-text-property (car interval) 'cmdbufmod)
       do (delete-region (car interval) (cdr interval)))
  (cl-loop for original in original-list do
       (goto-char (car original))
       (insert (cdr original))))

(defun cmdbufmod (bufmod-list fun &rest args)
  "After applying BUFMOD-LIST to current buffer run FUN with ARGS like `apply'.
BUFMOD is a list of buffer modifications. Each buffer modification
is a cons \(PLACE . NEWTEXT).
PLACE can be a regular expression or a function.
If PLACE is a function it should search for the next place to be replaced
starting at point. It gets the search bound as an argument,
should set match-data like `re-search-forward',
and return non-nil if a match is found.
If PLACE is a regular expression it is treated like the function
\(lambda () (re-search-forward PLACE nil t))

NEWTEXT can be a replacement string or a function.
A function should return the string for `replace-match'."
  (let (original-list)
            (setq original-list (cmdbufmod-prepare bufmod-list)))
          (apply fun args))
      (save-excursion (cmdbufmod-cleanup original-list)))))

(defconst org-table-multi-tblfm-re "[[:space:]]*#\\+TBLFM:"
  "Regular expression identifying \"#+TBLFM:\" at the beginning of lines.
Don't include a leading carret here!")

(defun org-table-multi-tblfm-search (&optional bound)
  "Search for next \"#\\+TBLFM:\"-line that is preceded by another such line.
If BOUND is non-nil search stops there or at `point-max' otherwise.
The match-data is set to the match of \"[[:space:]]*\n[[:space:]]*#\\+TBLFM:[[:\" at the beginning of line."
  (interactive) ;; for testing
  (let ((re (concat "[[:space:]]*\n" org-table-multi-tblfm-re "[[:space:]]*"))
    (while (and (setq found (re-search-forward re bound t))
                   (forward-line -1)
                   (looking-at-p org-table-multi-tblfm-re)))))

(defun org-table-multi-tblfm (oldfun &rest args)
  "Replace buffer local table formulas when calling OLDFUN with ARGS."
  (if (looking-at-p (concat "[[:space:]]*\n" org-table-multi-tblfm-re))
      (apply oldfun args)
    (cmdbufmod '((org-table-multi-tblfm-search . "::")) oldfun args)))

(advice-add 'org-table-recalculate :around #'org-table-multi-tblfm)
  • I have way too little elisp + Emacs internals knowledge to write up something like this currently, but this does look interesting! – Zelphir Jul 17 '18 at 14:09
  • @Zelphir You do not need to write anything up. You can just copy the stuff into your init file, restart Emacs, and use org-table-recalculate as you are used to it. All #+TBLFM: lines will be evaluated at org-table-recalculate. – Tobias Jul 17 '18 at 17:26

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.