I would like to write my own notes/tests/code in org and then use org-bable-tangle to produce source files. However, all of these files are subject to version control and hence subject to change from outside my org environment.

I would like to be able to have a number of src blocks and then tangle to a bunch of different files, each of which would be commit to version control. But at the same time, be able to "untangle" each of these files back into my org file after pulling any changes from version control.

Is there any straightforward way of doing this? I am now considering playing with insert-file-contents

  • Could you provide a little example of what you are asking to do? It sounds like you have code blocks in one or more org files and you want the file or files generated from the tangle of these blocks to disassemble into the original blocks with changes in the org files. – David D. Oct 5 '18 at 12:44
  • Essentially the workflow would be like this: (1) write some literate code in org. (2) tangle that code to one or more files. (3) git commit those files. (4) have lunch (5) git pull my colleague's changes. (6) "inverse-tangle" those changes back into code blocks in my org file. (7) goto (1). – RJTK Oct 5 '18 at 15:12

Yes, it's org-babel-detangle.

org-babel-detangle is an interactive compiled Lisp function in ob-tangle.el.

(org-babel-detangle &optional SOURCE-CODE-FILE)

Propagate changes in source file back original to Org file. This requires that code blocks were tangled with link comments which enable the original code blocks to be found.

You need to set the comments header argument to link to make it work, for example,

#+begin_src ruby :tangle hello.rb :comments link
  puts 'hello'

then use M-x org-babel-tangle to export the code block, a new file named hello.rb will be created, it should have similar contents like the following

~ $ cat hello.rb
# [[file:~/foo.org][No heading:1]]
puts 'hello'
# No heading:1 ends here
~ $

Finally, open hello.rb in Emacs, change hello to hello world, and run M-x org-babel-detangle in hello.rb's buffer. The org file will be updated

#+begin_src ruby :tangle hello.rb :comments link
  puts 'hello world'
  • Could you be more precise (or give an example) on how to use this org-babel-detangle function. I tried with your ruby code to use M x org-babel-detangle after tangling to hello.rb and modifying lightly the code but I have an error "org-babel-detangle: Wrong type argument: stringp, nil". – Lgen Oct 8 '18 at 20:10
  • @Lgen I've updated my answer. And don't forget to read org-babel-detangle's docstring to understand the purpose and the usage. – xuchunyang Oct 9 '18 at 1:12
  • Thanks for this clarification. I had not understood the assumption that the source code had to be edited within emacs to allow reverse tangling (I was using another text editor to modify the source code). It works as expected now. – Lgen Oct 9 '18 at 7:28
  • This is nice feature, but isn't quite what I was hoping to find. I can't really commit the #[[...]] comments since they don't mean anything except to myself. Is it possible to annotate a source block to detangle from an entire file without requiring the link comment? Essentially just insert-file-contents ? – RJTK Oct 9 '18 at 14:47

Your Answer

By clicking "Post Your Answer", you acknowledge that you have read our updated terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy, and that your continued use of the website is subject to these policies.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.