I have an interactive function taking 2 arguments. I can read them with

(defun example-fct (arg1 arg2)
  "This function take two arguments"
   (let ((arg1 (read-string "Arg1: "))
         (arg2 (read-string "Arg2: ")))
     (list arg1 arg2)))
  (message (format "input arg1=%s arg2=%s" arg1 arg2)))

Most of the time arg2 does not need to be entered. The default value is appropriate, and the second read is boring.

So I would prefer ask for arg1 and arg2 at the same time, something like a form. TAB switch between fields, ENTER (or other key) close the form and run the function.

-UUU:----F1  *scratch*      All (4,0)      (Lisp Interaction Fly AC WK ElDo
Arg1:                                  Arg2:


-UUU:----F1  *scratch*      All (4,0)      (Lisp Interaction Fly AC WK ElDo

How can I do this ?

I have look at magit transient, cus-edit.el and wid-edit.el (Are there any libraries for input fields in Emacs?) but I don't find.


When I run isearch-fordward in the completions buffer during a find-file command, I have a second field in minibuffer. Does any one know how to do this ? enter image description here

  • 1. completing-read-multiple may get you part-way there. 2. Icicles multi-completions provide what you request, but there are no doubt simple answers/workarounds also. – Drew Jun 19 at 13:45
  • Thanks. I have tried (completing-read-multiple "Arg1, Arg2: " nil). But it is more confusing, and I don't have same autocompletion for arg1 and arg2. – Balaïtous Jun 19 at 15:54
  • For multiple input fields, transient is the only option I am aware of. My brother has a already very useful stalled/unfinished tutorial on using transients, but using transient gets tricky for default values. – dalanicolai Jun 19 at 16:07
  • 1
    However, I do not know why you want it, but is it really so bad to read the colors sequentially? You could optionally only prompt for a second color when the command is prefixed with a universal argument. Also, I am not sure what colors you want to provide as options, but you might like to use the read-color function (and possibly modify it to make it accept default values). – dalanicolai Jun 19 at 16:15
  • Related: For Elgrep I had a similar problem at a larger scale. Elgrep has many options. To use all those options with sane default settings I provided a menu-driven input elgrep-menu with the help of the Widgets library. This is probably only relevant if your command gets more options with sensible default values. – Tobias Jun 20 at 5:49

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.